Don't know where you are but where I am, Mopar has a program where they will match an aftermarket price on body parts. Look into it with your dealership or body shop. I just had my front bumper replaced under the program and got OEM. I suspect this is not a local program. Good luck. Yes I would steer clear of those in any event. Mine was an insurance job but that shouldn't matter.
I tried the fiber glass plastic rout for my front once... Didn't even put it on... Went into the trash. Bought oem and never looked back.. So worth the cost